Are you in a hurry?
Here is a quick list of Hotels in Shelter Island, selected based on their rating
| Name of hotel | Accommodation Rating | Price, $ | |
| The Pridwin Hotel |
9.1 / 10 (78 Reviews) |
From 334$ | |
| Sunset Beach |
8.2 / 10 (8 Reviews) |
From 596$ | |
| Seven Resort Style Inn Near Beach |
9.9 / 10 (81 Reviews) |
From 262$ |
Welcome to Shelter Island, a picturesque and serene destination situated in the heart of Long Island's East End. If you're planning a trip to this charming island getaway, one of the first things you'll need to consider is your accommodation. While there are various options available, hotels continue to be a popular choice for travelers seeking convenience, comfort, and exceptional amenities. In this blog post, we'll explore the reasons why hotels are a fantastic choice when visiting Shelter Island.
First and foremost, hotels provide a level of convenience that other types of accommodations may not offer. With a wide range of options available, you can choose a hotel that suits your specific needs and preferences. From budget-friendly options to luxurious resorts, there is something for every traveler. Additionally, hotels often provide amenities such as on-site restaurants, fitness centers, and concierge services, making it easy to relax and enjoy your stay without having to worry about the logistics of finding food or entertainment.
Another advantage of staying in a hotel is the level of comfort they provide. After a long day of exploring Shelter Island's beautiful beaches, hiking trails, and charming villages, a comfortable bed and a relaxing environment are paramount. Hotels often prioritize comfort, offering plush bedding, spacious rooms, and soundproofing to ensure a good night's sleep. Some hotels even provide additional amenities like spas or swimming pools, adding an extra touch of luxury and relaxation to your stay.
In addition to convenience and comfort, hotels also provide a sense of security. When traveling to a new place, it's important to feel safe and secure in your accommodation. Hotels offer 24-hour front desk service, ensuring that there is always someone available to assist you. Additionally, many hotels have surveillance systems and secure entry procedures, giving you peace of mind during your stay.
Lastly, hotels offer a unique opportunity to connect with fellow travelers. Whether it's through hotel organized events or simply striking up a conversation in the hotel lobby, staying in a hotel can provide a chance to meet like-minded individuals who share a love for travel and exploration. The communal spaces within hotels, such as lounges or dining areas, create an inviting atmosphere for socializing and connecting with other guests, adding an extra layer of enjoyment to your trip.
In conclusion, when visiting Shelter Island, hotels are an excellent choice for accommodation due to their convenience, comfort, security, and social aspects. With a wide range of options available, you can find a hotel that perfectly suits your needs and preferences, offering a memorable and enjoyable stay on this enchanting island. So, pack your bags, book your hotel, and get ready to discover all that Shelter Island has to offer.
View all photos
The Pridwin Hotel
From 334$
Overlooking the private beach, Pridwin Hotel is within 10 minutes' drive of Railroad Museum of Long Island in Shelter Island. This 4-star hotel offers Wi-Fi in public areas, a car park on site and a swimming pool.
The accommodation is placed about 90 km from Long Island MacArthur airport and around 10 minutes' drive from such cultural venues as Nova Constellatio Gallery. Montauk is 36 km from the hotel, while Beall & Bell Antique Store is approximately 4.1 km away. The free beach is merely 50 metres away. The Pridwin Hotel is also within 10 minutes' drive of Greenport.
Cheap Hotels
View all photos
The 4-star Sunset Beach Hotel Shelter Island is located 20 minutes' walk from Crescent Beach and comprises 20 rooms with modern comforts. Sylvester Manor Educational Farm is placed a 5-minute ride away, and Railroad Museum of Long Island is a 10-minute drive from the luxury hotel.
The centre of Shelter Island can be reached within a 5-minute walk, and natural attractions like the locally run aquaculture Southold Bay Oysters Farm are 4 km away. Guests can go to Newport, which is a 75-minute drive from the romantic Sunset Beach Shelter Island. Families travelling to Shelter Island will enjoy being within 3.1 km of Greenport Antique Carousel.
Pet Friendly Hotels
View all photos
Seven - A Boutique B&B On Shelter Island, located at 500 metres from Shelter Island Country Club and about 10 minutes' drive from Mashomack Preserve, features a seasonal outdoor swimming pool for guests to take a dip in. Immerse yourself in the 4-star bed & breakfast's garden, complete with a terrace.
The property is placed about 85 km from Long Island MacArthur airport and a few metres away from Shelter Island Golf Course. New Haven is 55 km from the Seven - A Boutique B&B On Shelter Island, while Sylvester Manor Educational Farm is approximately a 20-minute stroll away. Nature lovers will appreciate the proximity to Crescent Beach, which is 1.3 km away. Greenport is 10 minutes by car from Seven - A Boutique B&B On Shelter Island.